Cultural Comparisons

vs170915-001
A few of my students in Sohar, Oman
Haitham, one of my brightest communications class students, stood in front of my desk nervously fidgeting with his notebook until I finally nudged him into telling me why he’d made an appointment to speak with me in the privacy my office. “I just wanted you to know I really admire your culture,” he said, emphasizing the word ‘your’ in an effort to express his dismay with his own.
“Really,” I retorted, with an amused expression on my face that I couldn’t seem to control. “I can think of a few aspects of American culture I don’t admire,” I added. In his most earnest voice, Haitham continued by explaining that he was actually referring to ‘standards’ which he felt were completely absent in Omani culture.

We continued our conversation for another 20 minutes or so as I tried to explain the positive aspects I clearly recognized in Omani culture, while admitting that having Western organizational skills and efficiency in task completion wasn’t always the ticket to happiness as evidenced by watching any international newscast.

As a Western teacher working in a conservative Middle Eastern country, I’d always tried to walk a fine line between encouraging my students to rise to the challenge of overcoming the provincial local attitudes that sometimes interfered with the learning process and saying anything that might be viewed as critical of their culture per se. In my classroom interactions, my aim was to motivate my students to improve their communication skills in a way that would enhance their contributions to the development of their country.

In Haitham’s case, it seemed clear that he felt stuck in a place that would inevitably limit his potential. My intent was to help him accept what he saw as the failings of his culture, and encourage him to not view them as a barrier to his academic and professional future. I suggested that he apply for one of the Omani government’s study abroad scholarships so he could experience the inner workings of Western culture first-hand.

From my conversations with other Omani students who had left the embrace of their home country to study abroad, I realized just how difficult adapting to a Western lifestyle would probably be for Haitham. I knew from my own experience as an expat how often I’d longed for silence at sunrise (always avoid living next to a mosque in Oman if you like to sleep in!), or craved restaurant cuisine that didn’t taste vaguely East Indian. “Yes, indeed,” I mentally whispered to myself.  This would be just the medicine Haitham needed to open his mind to the positive aspects of his culture.

“I just wanted you to know I really admire your culture,” he said…

I don’t think my words gave Haitham much comfort right at that moment, because I can still see the expression of sadness he wore as he exited my office. I couldn’t help feeling empathetic since I left the USA to live and work abroad at least partially because of the failings I saw in the culture of my own country.

Should I have pointed out to Haitham that America has a serious problem with violence, especially gun violence? He would have been forced to agree that this wasn’t a problem in Oman. When Oman’s wise Sultan came to power through a palace coup in 1970, he had been sure to remove weapons from the grasp of his country’s rival tribes.

Through his wise leadership, he had united the country under one banner and turned his Sultanate into a model of peace and prosperity. Of course, as I was continually reminded by my Western colleagues, the average Omani paid a price for this unity by not being allowed to criticize the Sultan’s decisions.

I wonder aloud now if the messiness of our own ‘democracy’ is truly worth the much-heralded freedom of speech Westerners prize so highly, or the right to bear arms that’s sacred to so many Americans. Is it necessary to give up some degree of safety and security in order to have the level of individual freedom most Westerners expect?

DSCN0692
My wonderful Omani neighbors

I could have perhaps improved Haitham’s mood by reminding him that there’s been ever-expanding disintegration within many American families as divorce rates have skyrocketed and individuals have placed greater importance on having their own personal needs met rather than the needs of the family unit. Most research indicates that this phenomenon has had wide ranging negative impacts on American society as the number of financially struggling single parent households has increased.

While the strong American work ethic is still mostly intact, it’s a fact that working single parents have less time to spend teaching their children to be good citizens or helping them with their studies. This in turn has led to an increased reliance on public education and, in addition, has become a major source of stress for already over-burdened teachers who are expected to somehow provide what’s lacking in students’ home lives.

Is it any wonder that many people claim there’s a crisis within the USA’s public education systems?  It seems to be convenient to lay the blame on public education or scapegoat LGBTQ culture for this disintegration, especially when there’s no easy answer to a problem produced by American culture in general.

A typical family in Oman, as well as in other collectivistic cultures around the world, place family cohesion and harmony above an individual’s needs. Even the most important decisions are made collectively by the family, or more precisely by the parents and older brothers in the case of younger female siblings.

I recall being completely shocked when a seemingly Westernized Omani friend nonchalantly told me that his family had selected the woman he would marry. He seemed resigned to tribal traditions which dictated that his mother and older sisters would choose his bride.

In this way, wealth is kept within the family and marriage is often merely a means of legally reproducing heirs to carry on the family name. Even if there is a divorce—yes, divorces do happen, even though they are much rarer than in the West—both the mother and father remain members of the extended family and the children stay in a secure environment.

The collectivistic tendencies within Arab culture are so powerful that Palestinian psychologist Marwan Dwairy’s research has noted that his Arab patients’ symptoms became more severe when self-actualization strategies were introduced into therapy. According to Dwairy, the notion that a patient’s  individual emotional needs should to addressed was seen as an attempt to take away the only real security they had ever known.

While unity, harmony and obedience are the hallmarks of many tribal societies, there’s also an ugly side that’s occasionally exposed. In some rural parts of the Middle East, where the need to preserve the public reputation of the family name is of utmost importance, extreme events such as honor killings still take place, although less frequently than in the past. This usually involves a disobedient daughter being killed by an older brother in order to remove the shroud of shame hanging over the  entire family unit.

So, which family model is more desirable? Does stability at all costs outweigh the freedom to choose, even when the choices we make may be selfish and not benefit others or the society at large?

Whenever I was having a particularly stressful day at the university where I taught, I would try to imagine myself wrapped in the comforting cocoon of family, country and religion that seemed to satisfy most of my Omani students so completely.

One thing I do feel certain about is that once Haitham’s awareness of his culture had been awakened, he would never again be able to see the world in quite the same way. As someone who was taught to think critically from an early age, I understand his dilemma.

Peace ~ henry

Advertisements

Author: Henry Lewis

Unconventional artist, writer, videographer and teacher. Personal Quote: It isn't easy being me ;-)

8 thoughts on “Cultural Comparisons”

  1. What an interesting blog post Henry! I d probably have the same initial reaction as you (Really???)😁 I’m also not so sure Haitham would have the same appreciation of Western culture once he ‘d experienced it more. Globalisation has opened up routes that weren’t there before, and as you have had your fair share of cultural “shocks” by living and teaching in the East, the same would go for an eastern man/woman if tables were turned.
    Think of all those people that had to migrate these last years so as to escape war or totalitarian regimes, and the dilemma they’re facing in finding their authentic voice in popular Western culture, balancing against their fears of cultural assimilation and loss of identity.They seek to know how is it possible to move toward the center of Western culture without compromising deeply-held religious beliefs and traditions. The thing is that religion offers them a totalized worldview encompassing all spheres of community interaction: political, economic, social, etc. The West isolates the spheres of knowledge and action and enshrines the individual. Despite overtones of “civic religion” in Western societies, they are extrinsically secular; traditional Muslims for example, are overtly committed to the sacred as the cornerstone of community and family life. Family can be really ‘immobile’ as a unit and tends to act as a barrier to its younger members, which sets the individual ‘free’ of having to make his/her own personal choices and consequently OWN them. So, if for your whole life you’ve been conditioned to think and live this way, how would you really cope with life in the West where personal growth, privacy and the ‘individual’ are so high in hierarchy? I’m not saying that it cannot be done, only that it’s challenging.
    ps. I thought I should also leave my comment here, and not just on Facebook 😉

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Your comments are very insightful Iliana. It does seem true that Islam is a religion that’s intricately woven into all areas of daily life, especially in the more traditional parts of the Middle East. Islam is also flavored by the traditional tribal societies from which it originated, and therefore, provides even deeper roots for many of its adherents. Many ‘religious’ Westerners tend to compartmentalize (at least to some extent) their work and home lives separately from their faith. These distinct differences in world view set up many hurdles for Muslim immigrants to overcome once settled in the West.Thanks so much for your comments and support of Quest Blog!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. What wonderful opportunities you’ve had to view other people and their society up close! I like the way you interacted with your student, how you encouraged him to pursue interests which obviously extend beyond his own culture while pointing out the positive qualities you’ve observed in it. It’s nice for him that you lent an empathetic and non-judgemental ear, allowing him to express his frustrations. At the same time giving him the benefit of your opinion about the culture in which you were raised.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks Kristy! I was often dubious of my ability to positively affect my students, but I did always try to support them with their struggles. I still feel the education they provided for me was superior to anything I shared with them.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. What a wonderful musing on the role of family in collectivistic cultures versus the cultures that focus on individual freedoms!!!!! When you said: “Does stability at all costs outweigh the freedom to choose, even when the choices we make may be selfish and not benefit others or the society at large?”……you hit the nail on the head—-dead on. When the stability of the family is of much greater importance than the needs of the individual, the fabric of the culture maintains full integrity……unlike in Western societies that are rife with social disorganization and all that goes along with it: divorce, violence, suicide, etc. There is a sickness that is on a roll right now in Western societies, gaining momentum. What breaks my heart is to see the traditional tribal societies being swayed into “modern behavior” by digital contact with the West. What they learn from watching YouTube videos, and tv shows and movies from the West….as well as their growing addiction to social media….all of it is ripping at the fabric of their traditional highly stable culture. Frankly, after living in a bunch of different cultures, I have to say that I prefer, BY FAR, the cultures that place the greatest importance on the unity of the family above the needs of the individual. They are happier and more peaceful cultures. The people I have known and befriended in those cultures are very spiritual people with a strength of character that is….well….awesome.

    The amount of drug and alcohol abuse is minimal in Oman. It exists, but it is very minimal in comparison to Western countries. There sure as heck isn’t an opiod epidemic!! Psychological counseling is relatively rare, too. Between the family support and the guidance of the “pastor” (imam), people tend to get back into balance pretty fast when they lose it.

    And that is something to be treasured….

    Thanks for your wonderful writing, and your thought-provoking perspectives. I truly enjoy reading ANYTHING you write. Even if it is a grocery list!!!!
    xoxoxoxoxoxoxox

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Hello Henry, it’s a joy to meet you. Excellent, thought-provoking post. My first overseas living/working experience was many years ago in Khartoum, Sudan, as a management consultant and teacher. It was many things – exhilarating, educational – but most of all, humbling. It instilled a worldview that sustains me today. I’m looking forward to more of your posts. All the best, Terri

    Like

    1. Thank you Terry for your comment. I agree that the experience of living and working in cultures that are very different from our own is a truly humbling experience. It’s the educational value of such travel that keeps me moving on. Thanks again for your support!

      Like

Leave a Reply to gallivance.net Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s